Billing Center

Want to save up to $75 a year? Select your company from the list below, complete and return the easy EFT form to us.

The Place For Billing Questions
If you receive your billing directly from the insurance company, all payments should be made directly to the company. We have provided links below that allow you to access their on-line bill payment sites. They also have special billing departments to answer all of the questions about your insurance bill. We have listed the phone number for easy reference. Please have your policy number ready.

American Modern Home
1-800-543-2466
8:00pm to 5:00pm
(eastern time), Monday trough Friday
Call with billing questions or to make a payment by Visa, Masercard
www.lovullo.com


A Central Insurance Company
1-866-222-2242

Pay by online checking, Visa, MasterCard
www.acentralinsurance.com



Adirondack Insurance Exchange
1-800-662-0156 

8:00pm to 5:00pm (eastern time), Monday trough Friday
Pay by Check, Visa, MasterCard, Discover, American Express

www.aie-ny.com


Donegal
1-800-877-0600 

Pay by Visa, MaserCard
www.donegal.com


Dryden Mutual
1-800-694-8271

Pay by Visa, MaserCard
mailto:billing@drydenmutual.com


Erie Insurance
1-800-458-0811

Pay by Check, Mastercard, Visa
www.erieinsurance.com


Foremost
1-800-527-3905
Pay By Online Checking, Savings Account, Master Card, Visa 
www.ForemostPayOnLine.com


Genesee Patrons
1-800-
Billing inquires only


GMAC
1-800-
Pay by on-line check, Mastercard, Visa
www.gmacinsurance.com



Hanover

1-800-573-1187

Pay by online Check, MasterCard Visa or Debit Card

www.hanover.com


The Hartford

1-800-962-6170

Pay by online Check, MasterCard, Visa or Discover
www.TheHartford.com


Hartford Steam Boiler

Contact the McMahon Agency, Inc.
Local #1-716-837-3943

Out of Area 1-800-837-3943, pin # HELP (4357)


Merchants Mutual
1-800

Pay by electronic Check (Do Not Except Credit Card Payment) 
www.merchantsgroup.com


Mercury
1-800-503-3734

8:15am to 4:15am, Monday through Friday 
Pay by Check, Master Card, Visa & Discover
www.mercuryinsurance.com


Michigan Millers Mutual
1-877-872-0494
Pay by Electronic Check, Master Card or Visa

www.michiganmillers.com


New York Central Mutual
1-800-234-6926
Pay by online Check, Master Card, Visa or Debit Card
www.nycm.com


Peerless
1-800-228-7830
Automated billing information available 24/7.
Pay by Check online

www.peerless-ins.com


Philadelphia
1-877-438-7459, #3
Pay by on-line check, Visa, Master Card, American Express & debit card
www.phly.com


Progressive

1-800-999-8781
www.Progressive.com



 

Safeco
1-800-332-3226
Payment by online check, Visa, Master Card, Discover, American Express & debit card
www.safeco.com


Travelers

Personal Insurance - 1-877-878-2468, #1
Business Insurance - 1-800-252-2268
Pay by on-line check, Visa or Master Card
www.Travelers.com


Utica First
1-800-456-4556, #8
Pay by on-line check, Visa, Master Card, Discover, American Express or debit card
www.UticaFirst.com


Zurich
1-800-332-6641
Pay by online check
www.ZurichNA.com